Growing up and even into my early adulthood I was raised under the illusion that I lived in a free and democratic society. When my children first entered the American educational system, I was swiftly disabused of that notion. It wasn’t the nation’s educational system, per say, that led to the abrupt and jarring confiscation of freedoms. It was something else. Something more authoritative and potent – the PTA.
The PTA where I live is so extraordinary that they have granted themselves a special name, a name more befitting their exceptional greatness. I can’t tell you what it is exactly because I fear for my life, but I can tell you we (because membership is enforced) are a community.
We are a community because a community is unassailable. A community is, by its very definition, a wonderful, loving, caring place, a nirvana comprised of committed and concerned individuals working together for the common good.
Except when you raise a differing opinion. Then you must be silenced.
This group is not nor ever shall be referred to as the PTA. The PTA is a lowly, pedestrian term for a lowly, pedestrian group. Not us.
Which brings me to Valentine’s Day. Valentine’s Day at my kids’ school can never simply be Valentine’s Day. It must be more. Because we are more.
This moreness, as it relates to Valentine’s Day, developed as a natural progression out of a particular problem the school faced a while back. The problem didn’t stem from Valentine’s Day – it originated, I believe, from birthday celebrations – but it had a explosive domino effect.
Several years ago a few unhappy individuals who I take to be influential in the Non-PTA PTA were dissatisfied with the snack levels they found in the schools. They brought their complaints to the administration, and the administration, stripped of its own decision-making powers, followed the dictates the Non-PTA PTA. As a cover for the fact that the ruling was to placate the preference of a select few, the administration included food allergies in the new law and decreed all outside food banned from classrooms.
While I found the measure to be a bit draconian and somewhat unwarranted particularly given the backroom nature of the dealings, I was just as happy to be unshackled from baking 29 cupcakes on a weekday night and somehow carting them all into school the next day intact. I was free, and I was happy.
But the Non-PTA PTA had other plans. Having the children go without a wonderful and memorable school birthday celebration was unthinkable. It was heartbreaking and cruel for little Storm or Kendall to not be celebrated by their classmates. And the Non-PTA PTA, never content to leave well enough alone, put their heads together to devise a plan. And they came up with an even better solution.
Instead of bringing in cupcakes, the children would now bring in little gifts for every child in class. With this measure, parents became obligated to bring in goodies for the entire class in addition to the four million goodie bags they had to purchase for their child’s actual birthday party. Note to Non-PTA PTA: If I wanted to give every kid in class a goodie bag I would have invited them to the party.
Then, for a while, things settled down. Seemingly, we had survived the worst of the fallout. Until, that is, the first holiday to fall under the new law rolled around.
Since the children were no longer permitted to eat communal party snacks and instead only allowed to eat snacks provided by their own parents, the Non-PTA PTA had to do some fast thinking to remedy the situation. And, they did. With detailed planning and a little foresight, they were once again able to take corrective measures.
For all holidays the Non-PTA PTA took it upon themselves to send home holiday-themed goodie bags for parents to fill with a special holiday treat of their choice for Kendall or Storm as well as a coordinated cut-out note card (in this case heart-shaped), which is to be used to write a special hand-written note of love to remind their precious child just how special and wonderful they really are.
Note to Non-PTA PTA: If I want to send in a special snack and/or write my kid a note I will do so, thanks.
And this is how the holidays are celebrated under a dictatorial regime.
I wonder what Valentine’s Day is like in North Korea.
photo credit: aussiegall via photopin cc


What a fucking joke. Seriously! What is it with PTA’s (or non-PTA’s) the world over? They call it P&C in Australia and they’re a bunch of control freaks who I’m sure were all teased at school so have made it their lifelong ambition to make misery for others. Now I live in England and it’s the same shit. Freaks.
Thank you for your support. I was afraid to hit that publish button, but it is somewhat nice to know that it’s the same the world over. That’s crazy, right? The craziest thing, too, is sitting there being like, “Um, am I the only one who is recognizing the insanity here?”
I feel your pain, glad those days are over. BTW, in North Korea they weave little heart-shaped mats out of grass, and then eat them.
I know. It’s awful. I didn’t know if I should really joke about that. But it was pretty funny.
OH MY GOD! I feel your pain. I was treasurer last year and I will NEVER DO IT AGAIN. Our school has a healthy snack policy but we get around it. But in all honesty what the hell are kids giving out Valentines for anyway? That’s not even what the day is for!
I know I got (slightly) involved just to do my fair share & I learned so much about how it’s run that I will never volunteer or donate money again. What a waste. I thought the PTA was supposed to improve the educational experience of the kids not waste time on nonsensical nonsense.
OH MY GOD! I feel your pain. I was treasurer last year and I will NEVER DO IT AGAIN. Our school has a healthy snack policy but we get around it. But in all honesty what the hell are kids giving out Valentines for anyway? That’s not even what the day is for!
I know I got (slightly) involved just to do my fair share & I learned so much about how it’s run that I will never volunteer or donate money again. What a waste. I thought the PTA was supposed to improve the educational experience of the kids not waste time on nonsensical nonsense.
Oh my goodness…it really does get carried away, doesn’t it. That’s why I stay uninvolved.
what a crazed bunch of loonies. poor kids. let’s spend just a bit more time on our science and math skills, pllleeeaaassseee.
Tell me about it.
Let’s spend just a bit more time on our science and math skills, pllleeeaaassseee. Is that what you meant?
what a crazed bunch of loonies. poor kids. let’s spend just a bit more time on our science and math skills, pllleeeaaassseee.
Tell me about it.
Let’s spend just a bit more time on our science and math skills, pllleeeaaassseee. Is that what you meant?
Yes, that’s what I meant. I think about how much time & money is wasted on nonsense when it could go toward improving our math & science skills.
That’s just insane… I’m now afraid for my sanity since my son is starting KG in September. Has the madness spread to my safe little island city? What awaits me?
High holy hell. Just home school.
That’s just insane… I’m now afraid for my sanity since my son is starting KG in September. Has the madness spread to my safe little island city? What awaits me?
OMG! And here I was LOOKING FORWARD to being a PTA mom!
Thank you for posting this. I will never, in this lifetime, sign up for this craziness!!!!!
OMG! And here I was LOOKING FORWARD to being a PTA mom!
Thank you for posting this. I will never, in this lifetime, sign up for this craziness!!!!!
I’m completely confused as to what the whole purpose of that whole exercise is….except if it to make parents completely insane, in which case, I completely get it!!
Yes, I think it is to drive me, specifically, insane.
I’m completely confused as to what the whole purpose of that whole exercise is….except if it to make parents completely insane, in which case, I completely get it!!
…wow. That’s nutters.
I’ve heard a lot of horror stories about PTAs…and now nonPTAs.
…wow. That’s nutters.
I’ve heard a lot of horror stories about PTAs…and now nonPTAs.